Use the brief to make the comparison fair.
Choose magnetic when the opening matters
A magnetic book-style or flap box creates a clear reveal and can work well for jewelry, beauty, fragrance and corporate kits. It is useful when the box is kept after purchase.
Choose a standard rigid format when simplicity matters
A lid-and-base or drawer box can be easier to stack, specify and repeat. It often makes sense when you want a robust presentation box without a magnetic closure.
Compare the interior first
A beautiful exterior will not solve product movement. The insert, clearance, closing pressure and product weight should be checked in the sample.
Quote both when uncertain
When the brief is early, comparing two structures with the same size and finish can help the team see the real tradeoff before choosing.